Choosing Heat & Airin Washington
All decisions

Start from your house

Heat, west side

Heat, east side

Oil, propane and wood

Cooling

Wildfire smoke

Damp, crawlspaces and ducts

Money and rules

Decisions Damp, crawlspaces and ducts Both sides

Should you insulate first or replace the equipment first?

Insulate and seal first or Equipment first

Compared by the people who run this site. Updated . Rebates and prices checked November 3, 2026.

Whether to insulate first or replace equipment first turns on whether the system still runs: if it does, seal and insulate first, because new equipment can then be sized to a smaller load. If it has failed, or you heat with baseboards and the attic is already done, do the equipment first.

The verdict, by situation

  1. If the system still runs and the attic insulation is thin

    Insulate and seal first. ENERGY STAR says air sealing and insulation can save up to 10% on annual bills, and sizing comes after.

  2. If the furnace failed in January

    Equipment first. Tell the contractor what insulation you plan, and ask for a Manual J that shows both cases.

  3. If you heat with baseboards and the attic is already done

    Equipment first. A 2008-09 metered pilot found Puget Sound homes saved 3,812 kWh a year with ductless, so compare the two.

  4. If the system runs but some rooms never get comfortable

    Air leaks and ducts first. ENERGY STAR says "Sometimes, these are the real sources of problems rather than your HVAC equipment."

  5. If the air conditioner died in an east-side July

    Equipment first. Dangerous summer heat can't wait, so read AC or heat pump and do the attic before the next summer.

  6. If your income is low enough for a free program

    Ask for weatherization before anything. Snohomish and Clark both point to free county programs, which may change the order for you.

Loose grey insulation between joists under the rafters of a brick-walled attic, lit by a small window.
Loose grey insulation between joists under the rafters of a brick-walled attic, lit by a small window.

Side by side

CompareInsulate and seal firstEquipment first
What it changesHow much heat the house needsHow that heat gets made
Official savings lineUp to 10% of annual bills (ENERGY STAR)Ductless saved 3,812 kWh a year in Puget Sound (2008-09 pilot)
Effect on sizingLowers the load the next system is sized toSized to today's load unless you plan ahead
RebatesPer square foot through utility contractorsPer unit, mostly for existing electric heat
Risk if skippedEquipment may be larger than the house later needsBills stay higher until the work is done
CodeNo order set for existing homes in the text checkedNew work sized by Manual S on Manual J loads, or an approved method
UrgencyCan usually wait for a good contractorNo heat in winter can't wait

Sources under the table: ENERGY STAR seal and insulate, NEEA field metering report, 2021 energy code. These savings figures are not comparable measures, one a share of bills and one metered kWh. A larger billing analysis of the same pilot found 1,677 kWh a year of space heating savings in Puget Sound. The table can't say which is larger in your house.

What would change the answer

  • The attic rebate only exists at low starting R-values. If yours is above R19, PSE's archived attic lines stop applying (archived copy, April 2026), so confirm with the utility.
  • Your equipment is old enough to prompt a review. ENERGY STAR's age prompts are more than 10 years for a heat pump or AC, and more than 15 for a furnace or boiler.
  • A contractor can do both in one visit, through one utility network. Timing stops mattering much.
  • Your ducts are the leak. Move duct sealing to the top of the list.
  • You are planning to move gas appliances out. The new air tightness and the new equipment may then belong in one plan.
  • A deadline applies, like Seattle's oil-to-heat-pump bonus. That can push equipment ahead.

What it costs, with dates

We found no official installed-price figure for insulation, air sealing or new equipment, so the dated numbers here are rebates. These are as of November 2026, and each needs the utility's contractors. Ask written bids to itemize square feet, starting and finished R-value, air sealing separately from insulation, and any bath fan or ventilation changes.

Insulation and air-sealing lines

UtilityAttic or floorAir sealing
PSEAttic R11 or less to R49, $1.75 per sq ft up to $3,500; attic R12-R19 to R49, $0.50 per sq ft up to $1,000; floor $2.50 per sq ft up to $5,000 (archived copy, April 2026), confirm with the utilityAttic or floor $0.20 per sq ft up to $400 each (archived copy, April 2026), confirm with the utility
Snohomish PUDInsulation $1 per sq ft, electrically heated homesNo separate line found
Clark Public UtilitiesFloor and attic $0.75 per sq ft; wall $1.20 per sq ft, electric heatAttic or crawl $100; whole house $300

Sources: PSE insulation rebates (archived copy, April 2026), Snohomish PUD, Clark. Avista lists a Home Insulation Program with no figure (archived copy, June 2026), so confirm with the utility. For fuel costs, see what heat costs.

Who does the work

Two trades usually handle this, and both can be checked on L&I's tool: an insulation or weatherization contractor, and an HVAC contractor. Rebates point you to each utility's list, so start there. Your own jobs are a look from the attic hatch, photos of what's there, a filter change, and a note of rooms that stay cold. If you burn gas or oil, ask how tightening the house affects those appliances.

Why does the order change the size of the new system?

Because sizing starts from how much heat the house loses. The federal consumer guide tells contractors to use Manual J and warns that oversizing can cost too much, give poor comfort and lead to mold.

Insulation and air sealing lower that load. If you do them after the new system goes in, the system may be larger than it needs to be. Washington's energy code also ties new equipment to Manual S and Manual J, or an approved method.

ENERGY STAR adds that improper installation can cut efficiency up to 30 percent, so the bid's sizing page deserves real reading. Your starting point is on the west side or east side page.

A red blower-door panel and orange fan fitted in a house doorway, with a kit bag on the floor.
A red blower-door panel and orange fan fitted in a house doorway, with a kit bag on the floor.

Is the old system safe to keep running while you insulate?

That depends on its yearly check and your CO alarm. Washington's health department wants oil and gas appliances checked yearly by a trained professional.

If a CO alarm goes off, get everyone out first, then call 911 from outside. Don't go back in to look for the cause.

A white house behind a snow-laden hedge at North 82nd and Sunnyside, Seattle, in 2008.
A white house behind a snow-laden hedge at North 82nd and Sunnyside, Seattle, in 2008.

Parts and examples

Sometimes the complaint is a room with a bad register, not a thin attic. Plumbing Supply and More, which shares an owner with this site, has a registers and grilles page that shows what a contractor might fit. It is useful for comparing, and it won't tell you whether a duct is the real cause.

What people ask next

Can I claim both an insulation rebate and a heat pump rebate?

We found no page that rules it out or promises it. Ask the utility in writing, since conditions differ. PSE's heat pump rule says to apply within 30 days of purchase (archived copy, May 2026), so confirm with the utility.

Is the attic the place to start in a Washington house?

We found no state ranking of attic, wall and floor. Clark's list rebates all three, so let a contractor's findings from your house decide. Rebate or wait covers the money side.

Decide next

Where this came from

Start from your house